ACE Rebrand Update: The Alliance for Citizen Engagement is now the Alliance for Civic Engagement.

Understanding the Debate on Chinese Tech Infrastructure and Surveillance Risk

chinese tech surveillance risk

Introduction

For many years, the United States has been worried about how Chinese technology could be a threat to national security. Over the past decade, prominent Chinese companies like Huawei, ZTE, Hikvision, and Dahua have grown quickly and built important parts of global communication and security systems. However, American officials are concerned that using this technology could put American data, safety, and military systems at risk. 

One major concern is that these companies might work closely with the Chinese government, especially given a 2017 Chinese law that says companies based in China must help the government with intelligence work if asked. Some American leaders believe this means that Chinese technology firms could spy on Americans, steal data, or even disrupt important systems. Because of these concerns, the U.S. government has taken several protective actions over the past few years. It has placed investment bans, federal procurement bans, and controlled exports on advanced chips and tools to limit how Chinese technology can be used in the U.S.. These steps are meant to protect American security and limit the risk of foreign control over critical systems.

Despite these allegations, Chinese technology companies deny that they are doing anything wrong. They say that the U.S. is acting unfairly and that there is no clear proof. Still, U.S. officials say the threat is serious enough to take strong precautions. 

How Chinese Technology Grew and Why It Matters to the U.S.

Over the past 20 years, Chinese technology companies have grown into some of the largest in the world. Companies like Huawei, ZTE, Hikvision, and Dahua make everything from cell phone networks to security cameras. These products are sold across the globe, including the U.S.. One reason Chinese technology grew so quickly is because it is often cheaper than products made by the U.S. or other European countries, thanks to government subsidies from China. Because of its low price, many importers choose Chinese equipment to save money, especially in small towns and developing countries.

However, this growth has caused concern in the U.S.. Some experts worry that if too much American infrastructure, like cell towers, security systems, or internet networks, is built with Chinese equipment, it could give China a national intelligence advantage. These analysts fear that Chinese companies could secretly collect data, listen in on conversations, or even shut down systems during a conflict. 

This matters to the U.S. because technology is now deeply embedded in the functioning of major systems such as hospitals, airports, schools, and even the military. If these systems rely on equipment made by companies that may answer to the Chinese government, it could put national security at risk. That’s why American leaders are paying close attention to where this technology comes from, who controls it, and what risks it might bring. 

U.S. Actions Against Chinese Tech

Over the years, the U.S. government has taken many steps to limit the use of Chinese technology. Below is a list of major actions in the order they happened:

  • 2012 – A report released by the U.S. House Intelligence Committee warns that Huawei and ZTE could pose a threat to national security. This is one of the first major instances of public concern regarding Chinese tech.
  • 2018 – The U.S. bans ZTE from buying American parts for breaking sanctions. The ban is later lifted, but only after the company pays a large fine. 
  • 2019 – The National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) is passed. Under this Act, American government agencies are banned from using equipment made by Huawei, ZTE, Hikvision, and Dahua. 
  • 2019 – The U.S. Department of Commerce puts Huawei on the Entity List, which makes it illegal for American companies to sell to Huawei without special permission.
  • 2020 – The FCC officially labels Huawei and ZTE as national security threats. This stops American networks from using government money to buy their equipment.
  • 2021 – The Secure Equipment Act is signed into law. It stops the FCC from approving new Chinese equipment from companies on the banned list. 
  • 2021-2022 – The “Rip and Replace” Program is funded. It helps smaller telecom companies remove and replace Chinese-made equipment from their networks. 
  • 2022 – The CHIPS and Science Act is passed. It provides billions of dollars to make computer chips in the U.S. and reduce reliance on Chinese technology manufacturing.
  • 2023 – The U.S. expands export controls, banning the sale of advanced computer chips and chip-making tools to Chinese firms like SMIC. 

These actions show that the U.S. is trying to reduce its dependence on Chinese technology and protect its communication and data systems. 

What Makes These Companies a Security Risk?

In addition to the concerns about companies working with the Chinese government, another concern is the idea of backdoors in technology, or hidden ways to get into networks or devices without being noticed. American experts believe Chinese technology might include backdoors that could allow China to spy on American networks, businesses, or even the government. This is especially worrying because Chinese equipment has been found in sensitive places like schools and military bases in the U.S.. If those devices are connected to networks, they could be used to watch people or send information back to China. 

Cybersecurity is another large issue. The U.S. has accused some Chinese companies of supporting hacking and cyberattacks by either sharing technology or creating weak spots that make it easier to break into systems. In addition, some of these companies, like Hikvision, have been linked to human rights problems in China, such as helping the government monitor people in Xinjiang. 

The Other Side of the Debate: China’s Claims and American Industry Concerns

Chinese companies and government officials strongly deny that they are a threat to American security. They say the U.S. is being unfair and trying to block competition from China’s fast-growing technology industry. In public statements, the Chinese government has called American actions “tech containment,” claiming that the bans and restrictions are not really about security, but about slowing down China’s rise as a technology leader. 

Companies like Huawei, ZTE, and Hikvision argue they are independent businesses, not controlled by the Chinese government. Huawei, for example, has offered to let other countries inspect its equipment and software to prove it’s safe. Other companies have even filed lawsuits in American courts, saying the bans are based on fear, not facts.

At the same time, some American companies and industry groups argue that broad bans can hurt American businesses too. For example, major American technology companies like Qualcomm, Intel, and Google have done business with Huawei and other Chinese firms in the past. When Huawei was placed on the U.S. Entity List in 2019, these companies lost a major customer, which hurt their earnings. Some groups in the telecom and agriculture sectors also worry that banning low-cost Chinese equipment could make it harder and more expensive to serve rural areas in the U.S. 

Key Takeaways

Concerns about Chinese technology have led the U.S. to take strong steps to protect its networks and data. At the same time, China and some American businesses argue that these actions may go too far or hurt economic interests. As the world becomes more connected through technology, finding the right balance between security, innovation, and global cooperation will remain an ongoing challenge.

[pvc_stats postid="" increase="1" show_views_today="0"]

Share this post

Related Briefs

Give feedback on this brief:

Free to read. Funded by people like you. Support the Fellows making it possible.