Key Takeaways
- Consumers used to be able to access information on the inner workings of their devices as well as replacement parts from manufacturers; as the result of a 1998 copyright law, however, those repairing modern devices found themselves in legal trouble, beginning the Right to Repair movement
- Advocates argue that Right to Repair is necessary to combat planned obsolescence by companies, reduce e-waste, and return control over purchased products to consumers
- Manufacturers and copyright holders argue that expanding Right to Repair laws will increase attempts at piracy and open consumers up to significant safety and data privacy concerns
- As more and more products integrate digital components, repairing them risks violating Section 1201 of the DMCA. This will heighten the importance of the Right to Repair debate
What is the Right to Repair?
According to Encyclopedia Britannica, the Right to Repair is a “legal concept that the owner of a piece of equipment, such as a vehicle or an electronic device, should be allowed to upgrade, modify, or repair it on their own, rather than having to rely on the equipment’s manufacturer to fix it or having to purchase a replacement.” In the U.S., this right is heavily limited by current copyright law.
When most people imagine copyright laws, they probably think of laws governing who gets to produce and profit from media like books and movies. Maybe they think of a Youtuber analyzing their favorite show and stating that all copyrighted material is used for commentary or educational purposes, and therefore, falls under Fair Use. Far fewer people know that a section of U.S. copyright law passed in 1998 has significant implications for the repair of products that many Americans use daily, including cellphones, garage door openers, wheelchairs, and tractors. It is even a major reason why, until recently, McDonald’s ice cream machines were seemingly always broken.
Though most Americans are unfamiliar with the modern Right to Repair movement, the right itself is far from new, and, in fact, used to provoke little controversy. Louis Rossmann, a Right to Repair activist and longtime electronics technician, explains in a 2020 Youtube video that the ability to repair products one owned used to be commonplace in the U.S.. Old electronics frequently came with diagrams and explanations of their inner mechanisms, as well as the ability to order replacement parts from the manufacturer so consumers could repair electronics should they break. However, due in large part to a change to U.S. copyright law in the late 1990s, the repair landscape has shifted considerably, sparking debate over whether consumers should have the right to fix and/or modify the products they own without the need for the involvement or approval of the original manufacturer, even when proprietary technology is involved.
What Does Copyright Law Have to Do With Repair?
In 1998, Congress passed the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA). The goal of the Act was to modernize U.S. copyright law in response to the rapid growth of the internet; due to this growing concern, Congress sought to ensure that copyright was well protected for digital works. Most relevant to repairing products is Section 1201, which prevents circumventing Technological Protective Measures (TPMs), also known as “digital locks.” TPMs are technologies, such as encryption or copy protection, intended to prevent access to, or duplication of, copyrighted material. For example, the Digital Rights Management (DRM) that is used to prevent Kindle books from being read on a competitor’s e-reader. The section also forbids trafficking in circumvention technologies. This means it is illegal to share tools that make it possible for others to break digital locks, such as by distributing software that allows a consumer to remove said DRM. While a technology to prevent the movement of e-books outside of a company’s ecosystem may not seem to have anything to do with repair, DRM has become commonplace. It is now found in a range of products, including those not usually thought of as digital. This means that the same law that bars a tech enthusiast from “jailbreaking” their PS5 so that it can operate as a Linux PC, can make it illegal to modify your air purifier to use cheaper off-brand filters, or to repair your thermostat.
It is possible to petition the Librarian of Congress for a temporary exemption to the circumvention prohibition; however, these exemptions last only three years, and do not automatically renew, even if they face no opposition. Additionally, it is not possible to receive an exemption to the anti-trafficking provision. This means that in practice, many otherwise-permitted repairs are suppressed because individuals sharing the software necessary to perform them put themselves in legal jeopardy, including a criminal penalty of up to $500,000 or five years in prison for the first offense. This even extends to devices no longer supported by their manufacturer, such as Google’s Nest Thermostat, which is still collecting user data from all Nest devices despite the company disabling remote control of the outdated models.
Who Has Access to the Right to Repair Today?
Currently, 10 states have active Right to Repair laws, but all 50 states have introduced Right to Repair bills. The laws, both proposed and passed, vary widely from state to state. Some states, like Nevada, cover only power wheelchairs, while others like Colorado cover a broader range of consumer electronics, like HVAC systems and farm equipment. As of January 1, 2026, just over a quarter of Americans live in a state with one or more Right to Repair laws.
What are the Arguments for Expanding the Right to Repair?
The primary argument advanced by advocates of Right to Repair is that the legislation protects consumers by ensuring that they will be able to fix products they own rather than being forced to buy new versions. Proponents of the Right also take the position that repair goes beyond replacing cracked screens or damaged batteries; they argue the Right to Repair also extends to the right to restore digital functionality. Currently, consumers can find themselves with a nonfunctional or lower-quality product when companies take servers offline or move existing features behind a new paywall. A fully realized Right to Repair, supporters say, will ensure that consumers can retain access to a product that functions as it did when they agreed to purchase it.
Advocates also emphasize the fact that, contrary to claims commonly made by manufacturers and copyright holders, independent repair does not pose increased risk to health and safety or data privacy for consumers. This is well supported by a 2021 Federal Trade Commission (FTC) report which found that manufacturers failed to submit evidence that substantiated these concerns. The FTC noted that “manufacturers provided no data to support their argument that injuries are tied to repairs performed by consumers or independent repair shops” and that “the record contains no empirical evidence to suggest that independent repair shops are more or less likely than authorized repair shops to compromise or misuse customer data.” The safety and efficacy of independent repair also holds true for medical devices. A 2018 FDA report found that “the objective evidence indicates that many [Original Equipment Manufacturers as well as] third party entities provide high quality, safe, and effective servicing of medical devices.” and that the “majority of comments, complaints, and adverse event reports alleging that inadequate ‘servicing’ caused or contributed to clinical adverse events and deaths actually pertain to ‘remanufacturing’ and not ‘servicing.’” The report also highlighted the importance of independent repair stating “the continued availability of third party entities to service and repair medical devices is critical to the functioning of the U.S. healthcare system.”
Additionally, many who champion Right to Repair do so for the economic and environmental benefits that can result from a decrease in the consumption of new products. Among these are a reduced demand for new materials, including rare earth metals, as well as a reduction in e-waste. E-waste, short for electronic waste, describes a broad category of discarded electronics including TVs, phones, computers, and video game consoles. It accounts for the majority of toxic waste currently in landfills and is projected to reach 82 million metric tons by 2030. Others make the case that repair itself will become cheaper because Right to Repair will prevent manufacturers from being able to monopolize the repair process and charge higher prices as a result.
Lastly, proponents contend that, especially in rural areas or in times of a supply chain disrupting crisis, such as COVID-19, the Right to Repair can be a matter of life and death. Currently, Biomedical Equipment Technicians frequently encounter problems accessing the information and/or parts they need, leading to delays in patient care, particularly in rural areas. Expanding the Right to Repair could enable hospitals to more efficiently keep critical equipment like ventilators and dialysis machines in working order.
What are the Potential Risks of Expanding the Right to Repair?
The most common argument against Right to Repair comes from manufacturers and copyright holders who assert that independent repair poses significant risk to consumers. As stated above, federal evaluation shows this to be largely unfounded. However, giving individuals the right to modify products, another tenet of Right to Repair, is more complex. For example, the National Association of Manufacturers notes that consumers sometimes modify products in ways that allow them to bypass EPA emissions limits or disable safety features.
Another argument given in opposition to Right to Repair is the potential of paradoxical economic and environmental effects if it is expanded. Researchers at UC Berkeley suggest that Right to Repair may incentivize manufacturers to compete with the secondhand market by lowering the price of new devices or by selling replacement parts at a high cost, as Apple has done. Both strategies could increase the consumption of new products and generate more e-waste. Additionally, increasing the lifespan of older products means products that are environmentally damaging will be in use longer, instead of being replaced by their more sustainable counterparts.
Some groups, such as the Competitive Enterprise Institute, a libertarian think tank, argue that Right to Repair laws can stifle innovation by requiring that products be manufactured in ways which enable independent repair. For example, they propose that some companies may choose not to add beneficial digital features (such as auto-off functionality on a flat iron) to their products in order to avoid being subject to Right to Repair laws. While others may return to producing bulkier or less water and drop resistant products because these sorts of designs are easier to bring into compliance with Right to Repair legislation than modern ultra-thin waterproof tech.
Finally the Cato Institute suggests that the wide variation in Right to Repair laws across the country is confusing for both consumers and manufacturers. They propose that this “patchwork of state laws” is likely to result in a scenario where the state with the most costly regulations indirectly becomes the default for the whole country, as manufacturers seek to adhere to a single set of rules that will allow them to do business in every state.
What is the Future of Right to Repair?
According to the Public Interest Research Group, by September of 2026, more than a third of Americans will be covered by at least one Right to Repair law. This, combined with research that shows, when provided with a description of Right to Repair, 86% of Americans say that they support it, suggests the push to expand Right to Repair will grow in the future, especially as an increasing number of mundane and necessary products come to possess the sort of proprietary technology governed by Section 1201 of the DMCA. Additionally, New York recently passed a bill that will require consumer electronics to come with a repair score on a scale from 1–10, reflecting the product’s overall repairability. This system is already in place in the EU and may spread throughout the U.S. in the coming years.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the penalty for violating DMCA Section 1201?
Civil penalties for violation vary. A violation that is willful and for profit faces a federal criminal penalty of a fine of up to $500,000 or 5 years in prison. Any further violations face an even steeper penalty.
What are the current congressionally approved exemptions to DMCA Section 1201?
The current list of DMCA Section 1201 exemptions, which began in 2024 and will be up for review in 2027, can be found here.
What is the current status of Right to Repair legislation in my state?
Check this map from the Repair Association for up-to-date information